you're reading...
[Other rambles....]

War and romance in the world of shoujo?

I never get it.

Why on earth do I ever get so sucked in to a periodic romantic drama, be it TV, movie or in particularly, shoujo manga!

But on the contrary, for some odd reason, I have always found it hard to be engaged in a WWII related story, in regardless.

.. Then I came across to this earlier this evening… and it suddenly “clicked”!

…. hence now I have a new theory for myself:

You see, in living in a true shoujo fantasy world, where “reality” is strictly forbidden! A WWII related story, regardless how good it may be, however reminds me of the cruel and cold-hearted reality! Basically, my attention span falls short whenever a WWII topic is near (unless I put my seriously-interested-in-history hat on)!

On the other hand, if the story is put in a historical context but in a far-far-away-distant past, which means then it will be easier for me to apply my ever-creative imagination of shoujo fantasies!… and then it goes back to the point raised about love and romance in war:

“Romance, the high-flown, sentimental, overwhelming passion between a man and a woman, pulled people into its orbit during the war as it had not for many years….. The war simply raised the stakes.”


What’s the point of this post? Well, I guess whilst I just wanted to share with you here some of my favourite historical settings of  shaonu manhua and shoujo manga, one may have spotted the common theme of war (or battles) and romance in these stories?…..


(For those who are interested in the History of China can have a look here)

Eastern Han of Imperial China (東漢) 

If you have watched the movie, Red Cliff, then you would probably be familiar with one of its character, Zhou Yu (周瑜), who had played a crucial role during the Battle of Red Cliffs in 208 AD.

The beautiful romance between Zhou Yu and his wife, Xiao Qiao (小喬) were often used as the theme for historical romance novels and manhua, such as Wedding Theme 嫁情曲 by Lu Xiang Ru (呂相儒).

Western Jin Dynasty (五代西晉年)

The Pearl Grudge 珍珠怨 is a manhua by Ou Bi Feng (歐碧鳳), written by Wu Man Chi, set in the Western Jin period of Imperial China when Emperor Hui succeeded the throne following the death of his father, Emperor Wu, in 290 AD. In reality, it was the emperor’s wife, Empress Jia Nanfeng who had truly exerted power thus empowering her family and the Jia clan at the courts.

The story of The Pearl Grudge  was written based on a poem, The Garden of the Golden Valley 金谷園 by Du Mu (杜牧) (803–852) who was a leading Chinese poet of the late Tang Dynasty. In particular, the last line of this famous poem, “落花猶似墜樓人” (meaning “flower petals are falling as if a falling person from the tower”) referred to a historical figure, Lu Zhu (綠珠, meaning “green pearl”) and her tragedy romance with Shi Chong (石崇)in the Western Jin Dynasty. (NB. In the poem, “THE tower” refers to the tower in the Garden of the Golden Valley, which was an estate and villa owned by the wealthy Shi. On protecting her virtues and loyalty to Shi, Lu Zhu jumped to her death from the tower after Shi was defeated by his political opponents….)

Northern Song Dynasty (北宋朝)

Sometimes ago, I have written a [Manga Talk] on Proclaiming and Loving 宣和戀 by Yi Huan (依歡), which is a manhua set in the Xuan He period of Northern Song Dynasty (1119- 1125). At the time of writing that [Manga Talk], my focus was more on the story-line itself (i.e. the entangled relationship between the girl and two other men, etc).

But to be fair, what I should have also pointed out then, was the fact that the author had shown us delicately her hard work in research for matching her story as closely as possible to the actual history.

For instance, some historical events such as Jingkang Incident 靖康事變 (1126- 1127), were used to depict the rotten dynasty at its peak of corruptions and political tug-of-wars inside imperial courts.

Nonetheless, Yi Huan had not forgotten to also depict those technology innovations at the time, for instance, the use of movable woodblock (technology) in printing, which was one of the four greatest inventions of China in history.

The story continued in its sequel, Real and Fake Princess 真假公主, after Jingkang Incident when the defeated imperial family was forced to flee and re-establish in the south at Lin’an – The new Southern Song Dynasty was formed….

Ming Dynasty (明朝)

The naval history of China dates back to the early Ming Dynasty, when Zheng He (鄭和) commanded seven voyages expeditions between 1405 to 1433. It was during those times when the imperial China became a leader of naval power. Zheng He’s great voyages were designed to re-establish diplomacy and large-scale maritime trade with the West, as well as to defeat suppress pirates which had continued to pose threats and challenges to the imperial courts.

The exotic theme of pirates as well as culture-exchange between the east and west were depicted in Yi Huan’s (again!) Spirit of the Oceans 碧海精靈.


The history of imperial China, or Zhong Yuan (中原) as it was known in the ancient times, often intervened with the ancient neighboring countries, such as the ancient Qiuci (龜兹) and Wusun (烏孫) of the Western Regions (西域三十六國) and The Xiongnu (匈奴) during Han Dynasty of China, as well as the Khitan Empire (契丹國) and Kingdom of Dali (大理國) during Song Dynasty..

Whilst those neighbouring empires posed military threats to the imperial China, political alliances were formed by “marrying off” the Chinese imperial princesses/ concubines to some foreign countries in order to form alliances in those days.


In the world of shounu manhua, this kind of “alliance-marriages” was often used in a story to tell a romantic tragedy, for instance Song of Xinjiang (??) 細疆曲 and Broken Arm Princess 斷腕公主 , both by Hou Cai You (侯采佑)…… or a comedy such as  Li Ren Man 儷人蠻 by You Gui Xiu (游圭秀), about a Mongolian princess forcing her way into the imperial family! Eventually, she had to leave Zhong Yuan to return home – BUT first, she had to capture her “targeted” before her great departure!!

Next: to continue with my favourite historical settings of classical Japan in the world of shoujo manga….



No comments yet.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

Follow [Manga Talk] on WordPress.com

Copyright & Disclaimer

© 2000 [Manga Talk]. Please do not use contents without permission. Manga images mostly nicked from web (unless otherwise specified), all ©original creators.
%d bloggers like this: